Write down what you will change before the listing numbers come in
A one-page pre-commitment for a listing's marketing review: which counts you will look at, and which change each outcome would trigger, written before the first report.
Listing reports are easy to read in whatever direction you already lean. A seller worried about the price sees a price problem; an agent proud of the photos sees a market problem.
One way to keep the review honest is to write the decision down before the numbers arrive. This note describes that method. It is a method, not a finding, and we do not claim it improves outcomes.
The page you write first
Before the listing's first report, write four short lines on one page and date it:
- the counts you will look at, such as online views, saved listings, inquiries, showings booked and showings held
- the review date, chosen in advance
- for each count, the change you would make if it looked low, and the change you would make if it looked fine
- who will make the call, the seller or you
Keep the changes concrete. "Review the price" is a topic, not a change. "Ask the seller for a price conversation at the next review" is a change.
Why the order matters
If you write the page afterward, the numbers shape the story. If you write it first, the numbers can only confirm or disconfirm a plan that already exists.
The page also gives the seller a way to see that you are not moving the goalposts.
What counts as low
You do not need an industry benchmark to start. Use your own earlier listings in the same price band as the reference, and say so on the page: for example, "low means fewer inquiries than my last listing in this band at the same point."
If you have no earlier listing to compare, write that down, and treat the first review as a baseline rather than a verdict.
At the review
Open the page, then open the report. For each count, mark whether it matched what you expected, and carry out the change you wrote, or write one line explaining why you are departing from it.
A departure is allowed. An unexplained one is the thing to avoid.
If a count could not be measured, say so on the page rather than substituting a different count.
Keep the record
File each page beside the listing's report. After several listings you will have a record of which changes you made, in what order, and what you were looking at when you made them. That record is your own, and it is more useful than a general rule.
Email sign-up is not available yet; new notes appear on this site and in its feed.